Automorphisms
Automorphisms of Rational Curves
Automorphisms of the projective line \({\P}^1\) are well-known to be \(3\)-transitive — for any three distinct points \(p_0\), \(p_1\), and \(p_\infty\), there exists an automorphism taking \(0 = (0:1)\), \(1 = (1:1)\), and \(\infty = (1:0)\) to \(p_0\), \(p_1\), and \(p_\infty\). Conversely, the images of \(0\), \(1\), and \(\infty\) uniquely characterise an automorphism. We use this characterisation of isomorphisms to define automorphisms of rational curves as bijections of three element sequences of points over the base ring.
- Automorphism(C, S, T): CrvRat, SetIndx, SetIndx -> MapIsoSch
Given a rational curve \(C\) and two indexed sets \(S = \{ p_0, p_1, p_\infty\}\) and \(T = \{q_0, q_1, q_\infty\}\), each of distinct points over the base ring of \(C\), returns the unique automorphism of \(C\) taking \(p_0\), \(p_1\), \(p_\infty\) to \(q_0\), \(q_1\), \(q_\infty\).
Automorphisms of Conics
The automorphism group of a conic, and indeed the conics themselves, have a special relationship with quaternion algebras (see Lam [Lam73] or Vignéras [Vig80]). For the sake of exposition we focus on conics \(C/K\) defined by a Legendre equation
where \(abc \ne 0\). We define a quaternion algebra \(A\) over \(K\) with anticommuting generators \(i\), \(j\), and \(k = c^{-1}ij\) satisfying relations
and setting \(I = ai\), \(J = bj\), and \(K = ck\). Then for any extension \(L/K\) we may identify the ambient projective pointset \({\P}^2(L)\) with the projectivisation of the trace zero part
of the quaternion algebra \(A_L = A\otimes_K L\) via \((x:y:z) \mapsto xI+yJ+zK\). Under this map, the pointsets \(C(L)\) are identified with the norm zero elements
in \({\P}^2(L)\). This allows us to identify the automorphism group \({\Aut}_K(C)\) with the quotient unit group \(A^*/K^*\) acting on each \(A_L^0\) by conjugation.
In the Magma implementation of this correspondence, the quaternion algebra \(A\) is computed and stored as an attribute of the curve \(C\). Automorphisms of \(C\) can be created from any invertible element of the quaternion algebra. We note that the isomorphism of two conics is equivalent to the isomorphism of their quaternion algebras, and that a rational parametrisation of a conic is equivalent to an isomorphism \(A \cong <Meta>-_2(K)\).
We note that while the advanced features of finding rational points (and hence finding parametrisations) and determining isomorphism exist only over the fields named in their descriptions, it is possible to represent the automorphism group and find automorphisms of the curve independently of these other problems. A Legendre model does not exist in characteristic \(2\). There QuaternionAlgebra(CrvCon) reads the algebra off the defining quadratic form directly, IsIsomorphic(CrvCon, CrvCon) compares those forms and requires a finite base field, and Automorphism(CrvCon, AlgQuatElt) acts by the same conjugation as in odd characteristic, through the matrix that QuaternionAlgebra(CrvCon) returns, but on \(C\) itself rather than on its dual conic.
- QuaternionAlgebra(C): CrvCon -> AlgQuat, AlgMatElt
Returns the quaternion algebra in which automorphisms of the conic \(C\) can be represented, and a matrix \(M\) relating a coordinate vector \(v\) of the plane of \(C\) to the trace zero part of the algebra through \((x, y, z) = vM\). In odd characteristic the trace zero part is spanned by \(i\), \(j\), and \(k\), and the norm of \(xi + yj + zk\) is a nonzero multiple of the adjoint form of \(C\) at \(v\). So \(M\) identifies the dual conic of \(C\), the zero locus of that form, with the norm zero elements of that part; it does not in general send the points of \(C\) to them. In characteristic \(2\) the algebra is presented as by the general constructor, with \(i^2 + i = \alpha\), \(j^2 = \beta\), and \(ji = (i+1)j\) for some \(\alpha\) and \(\beta\) in the base field of \(C\). Its trace zero part is spanned by \(1\), \(j\), and \(k\), since \(1\) has trace \(0\) there, and the norm of \(x + yj + zk\) is a nonzero multiple of the defining form of \(C\) at \(v\), so \(M\) identifies \(C\) itself with the norm zero elements of that part.
- Automorphism(C, a): CrvCon, AlgQuatElt -> MapIsoSch
Given a conic \(C\) and a unit \(a\) of the quaternion algebra associated to \(C\), returns the automorphism of \(C\) corresponding to \(a\). Through the matrix \(M\) returned by
QuaternionAlgebra, it is the conjugation \(\alpha \mapsto a^{-1}\alpha a\) of the trace zero part, acting on the points of \(C\) in characteristic \(2\) and, in odd characteristic, on the tangent lines of \(C\), the points of its dual conic. So for units \(a\) and \(b\),Automorphism(C, a*b)equalsAutomorphism(C, a) * Automorphism(C, b), the map that appliesAutomorphism(C, a)first.
- IsIsomorphic(C, D): CrvCon, CrvCon -> BoolElt, MapIsoSch
Given conics \(C\) and \(D\) over the same field, returns
trueif and only if they are isomorphic, and if so an isomorphism from \(C\) to \(D\) as the second value. In odd characteristic the conics are compared through their quaternion algebras, which requires the field to be \({\Q}\), a number field, a finite field, or a rational function field over a finite field. In characteristic \(2\) their defining quadratic forms are compared directly, which requires the field to be finite.
- Example: Automorphisms of a Conic Without Points (ex-85304b)
Run in calculator (opens in a new tab)
In this example we demonstrate how to use the quaternion algebra of a conic to construct nontrivial automorphisms of the curve when no rational points exist over the base ring. (We use the printing level
Minimalto produce human readable output for scheme maps.)> P2<x,y,z> := ProjectiveSpace(Rationals(), 2); > C0 := Conic(P2, 2*x^2 + x*y + 5*y^2 - 37*z^2); > HasRationalPoint(C0); false > BadPrimes(C0); [ 3, 37 ] > A := QuaternionAlgebra(C0); > RamifiedPrimes(A); [ 3, 37 ] > B := Basis(MaximalOrder(A)); > B; [ 1, 1/52*i + 1/4*j + 2/481*k, j, 1/2 + 1/148*k ] > m1 := Automorphism(C0, A!B[2]); > m1 : Minimal; (x : y : z) -> (-5/8*x + 259/48*y - 37/3*z : 37/12*x + 69/8*y - 74/3*z : x + 7/2*y - 61/6*z) > m2 := Automorphism(C0, A!B[3]); > m2 : Minimal; (x : y : z) -> (x + 1/2*y : -y : z) > m3 := Automorphism(C0, A!B[4]); > m3 : Minimal; (x : y : z) -> (-x - 1/2*y : 1/5*x - 9/10*y : z) > [ Trace(B[2]), Trace(B[3]), Trace(B[4]) ]; [ 0, 0, 1 ] > m1 * m1 : Minimal; (x : y : z) -> (x : y : z) > m2 * m2 : Minimal; (x : y : z) -> (x : y : z) > m3 * m3 : Minimal; (x : y : z) -> (9/10*x + 19/20*y : -19/50*x + 71/100*y : z)
The last example points out that pure quaternions \(\tau\) in \(A_0\) give rise to involutions — a reflection of the projective plane about the point defined by \(\tau\) in \({\P}^2(K)\).
One of the strengths of the scheme model in Magma is the ability to work with points of a curve over any extension. Provided that we have a rational point over some extension field \(L/K\), we are able to apply automorphisms of the curve to generate an unbounded number of new points over that extension by means of the action of the automorphism group. We demonstrate this by looking at quadratic twists of the curve to find a point over \({\Q}\), which identifies a point on the original curve over a quadratic extension.
> C1 := Conic(P2, 2*x^2 + x*y + 5*y^2 - z^2); > HasRationalPoint(C1); false > C2 := Conic(P2, 2*x^2 + x*y + 5*y^2 - 2*z^2); > HasRationalPoint(C2); true > RationalPoint(C2); (-1 : 0 : 1)
This gives rise to the obvious points \((\pm 1 : 0 : \sqrt{74}/37)\) on the original curve.
> P<t> := PolynomialRing(RationalField()); > L<a> := NumberField(t^2 - 74); > p := C0(L)![1, 0, a/37]; > m1(p); (1/1880*(207*a + 3034) : 1/940*(-37*a + 2146) : 1) > m2(p); (1/2*a : 0 : 1) > m3(p); (-1/2*a : 1/10*a : 1)
We could alternatively have formed the base extension of the curve to the new field \(L\) and used the known point over \(L\) to find a parametrisation of the curve by the projective line. This approach demonstrates that it is possible to work with points and curve automorphisms without passing to a new curve.